Sell your Toyota Highlander on Long Island
You can sell your Toyota Highlander at any of the 8 CarPresto dealerships on Long Island. You do not need a Toyota store. Start with a market estimate online, then book a free appraisal for a firm offer good for 7 days.
Start with your VIN or plate

- 10dealerships in the CarPresto network
- 2 minto get your market estimate
- 7 daysyour firm offer stays good
Where can I sell my Toyota Highlander on Long Island?
You do not need a Toyota store. Book at whichever is easiest.
| Store | City | Appraisal hours |
|---|---|---|
| South Shore Subaru | Lindenhurst, NY | Mon 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM, Sat 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM |
| Grand Prix Subaru | Hicksville, NY | Mon 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM, Sat 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM |
| Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge Ram | Jericho, NY | Mon 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM, Sat 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM |
| Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge Ram | Hempstead, NY | Mon 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM, Sat 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM |
| Merrick Jeep Chrysler Dodge Ram | Wantagh, NY | Mon 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM, Sat 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM |

What should I check on my Toyota Highlander before I sell it?
Confirm whether your Highlander is a gas or hybrid model, and whether it has seven or eight seats. Note XLE, Limited or Platinum trim and all-wheel drive. The third row and cargo area show family wear first, so check those before you answer the condition questions.
Should I sell or trade in my Toyota Highlander?
No CarPresto dealership on Long Island sells new Toyota vehicles, so a trade goes toward a car from the store that buys yours, such as a new Subaru, Jeep, Chrysler, Dodge, Ram, Ford, Alfa Romeo or Volvo. If you sell your Toyota Highlander outright instead, the buying store pays by check at handoff. Your firm offer on Long Island is the same either way, and the $500 bonus applies to both.
Read the guides
Will CarPresto buy my Toyota Highlander?
- It runs, drives and is model year 2016 or newer.
- Most vehicles qualify up to 125,000 miles, and some makes and models above that.
- You are within about 75 miles of a participating dealership.
- Salvage, flood, rebuilt and other branded titles do not qualify.
What is registered on Long Island?
Long Island has about 148,100 registered Toyota vehicles from model year 2016 or newer, 10.0% of recent vehicles there.
| County | Bar showing the count | Registered | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suffolk | 80,100 | 10% | |
| Nassau | 68,000 | 9.9% |
The DMV counts makes, not models, so this shows all Toyota vehicles. These counts show what is on the road, not what any car is worth. Source: New York DMV vehicle registrations, retrieved 2026-11-03.

What do I need to sell my Toyota Highlander in New York?
- Complete Transfer by Owner on the back of the title, only at the sale.
- Never cross out, erase or correct the title. The DMV rejects it.
- Add the damage disclosure, plus the odometer disclosure for 2011 or newer.
- Remove your plates and registration sticker before the sale is complete.
- Return the plates to a DMV office as soon as possible, unless you transfer them.
Source: New York DMV, checked 2026-11-04.
For your Toyota Highlander appraisal at South Shore Subaru in Lindenhurst, bring your title or loan details, registration, driver license and all keys and fobs.
What affects my Toyota Highlander trade-in value?
- Hybrid or gas powertrain.
- XLE or Limited trim.
- All-wheel drive.
- Interior family wear.
Questions sellers ask
- How do I sell my Toyota Highlander on Long Island?
- Enter the VIN or plate, mileage and ZIP. CarPresto checks eligibility and shows a market estimate. You then book a free in-person appraisal at a nearby CarPresto location, where you get your firm offer.
- Which CarPresto store should I use on Long Island?
- South Shore Subaru in Lindenhurst is a good place to start. You can book your appraisal at any store that suits you.
- How old can my Toyota Highlander be?
- CarPresto looks at Toyota Highlanders from model year 2016 or newer that run and drive. Older ones and branded titles do not qualify.
- Are there fees to sell my Toyota Highlander?
- No. There is no listing fee, appraisal fee or processing fee. A firm offer is made only at your in-person appraisal.
- How much can I sell my Toyota Highlander for?
- Enter your VIN or plate, mileage and ZIP for a market estimate. Your firm offer comes at a free in-person appraisal.
- Can I sell my car to a dealership if I'm financing it?
- Yes. The buying dealership verifies the payoff, pays the lender and pays you any remaining equity once the paperwork is signed.
Last updated
Sell your Toyota Highlander on Long Island
Get my estimateRelated CarPresto pages
- Sell my car on Long Island
- Sell my Toyota on Long Island
- Sell my Toyota RAV4 on Long Island
- Sell my Toyota Camry on Long Island
- Sell my Toyota Tacoma on Long Island
- Sell my Toyota Highlander
- South Shore Subaru, Lindenhurst
- Grand Prix Subaru, Hicksville
- Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge Ram, Jericho
- Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge Ram, Hempstead
- Merrick Jeep Chrysler Dodge Ram, Wantagh
- Compare ways to sell
- FAQ
