Skip to main content

Market estimate vs firm offer: what's the difference?

The number CarPresto shows you online is a market estimate. It is built from recent sales of similar cars near your ZIP, is good for 7 days and is not an offer. A firm offer is issued only at your free in-person appraisal and stands for 7 days, to an exact date and time.

Published by CarPresto. Operated by VIP Automotive Group. Last updated . Sources are listed at the end.

Key takeaways

  • The online number is a market estimate, good for 7 days.
  • A market estimate is not an offer, and nothing is signed when you see it.
  • A firm offer comes only at the in-person appraisal and stands for 7 days.
  • The firm offer depends on the car matching your answers, plus title and payoff checks.
  • You can decline a firm offer with no penalty until you sign.

What is a market estimate?

A market estimate is the figure a dealer can reasonably be expected to pay for your car, based on recent sales of similar vehicles near your ZIP and what you told us about it. With CarPresto it is good for 7 days, and the date is shown with it.

The estimate is adjusted for your mileage, trim, options and the condition you report. When enough recent sales exist, we tell you how many we used. It takes about two minutes to get one, and there is nothing to sign.

A market estimate is not an offer. No car has been looked at yet, so it is a starting point for the appraisal. It is not a promise to buy at that number. The full rules are in our Offer Terms.

What is a firm offer, and when do you get one?

A firm offer is the amount a VIP Automotive Group dealership will pay for your car, and you get it only at your free in-person appraisal at a CarPresto location. It stands for 7 days, and the exact expiration date and time are printed on it and in your portal.

The firm offer also states your $500 bonus and names the dealership buying the car. While your appraisal request is with our team, our dealerships line up their best offer for your car. The visit takes about 30 minutes.

A firm offer is subject to the car matching what you told us, plus title and payoff verification. You can accept it or decline it with no penalty. Once you accept and sign, the number you accepted is the number you are paid, less any loan payoff we make for you.

How do a market estimate and a firm offer compare?

The two numbers come at different steps, rest on different information and carry different weight. The table puts them side by side.

Market estimate and firm offer at CarPresto
Market estimateFirm offer
: Where you get itMarket estimate: Online, in about two minutesFirm offer: At your free in-person appraisal
: What it is based onMarket estimate: Recent sales near your ZIP and your answersFirm offer: Your answers plus what the appraiser sees
: How long it lastsMarket estimate: 7 days, date shownFirm offer: 7 days, to an exact date and time
: Is it bindingMarket estimate: No. It is not an offerFirm offer: Yours to accept or decline until you sign
: What can change itMarket estimate: What the appraisal finds in personFirm offer: The car differing from your report, or title and payoff checks

Is my online estimate a firm offer for 7 days?

No. The 7-day window belongs to the market estimate, and the 7-day window starts only when a firm offer is issued at your appraisal. The two windows can be the same length, and they start at different times and cover different numbers.

If your firm offer expires before you decide, you can request a refreshed offer from your portal. Market prices move, so the refreshed amount can be higher or lower. The estimate vs offer answer in our FAQ says the same thing in short form.

Why can my firm offer differ from my market estimate?

Your firm offer can differ because the estimate uses only what you reported online, while the appraiser sees the car in person. When the numbers differ, we show you exactly what we found and how it changes the number.

Differences are usually condition items that did not come up online, such as a warning light, tire wear or a repair that was not mentioned. Honest answers in the condition step are the best way to keep your firm offer close to your estimate.

Declining costs nothing and you keep your car. The appraisal differences answer covers what happens next.

How do online instant offers from other buyers usually work?

Many online car buyers label the first number they show an offer. In most cases that number still depends on an inspection, or on the car matching your answers, before the sale goes through. The inspection can lower it.

Before you count on any online number, read the terms. Check how long it lasts, what can lower it, whether any fees come off it and when you are paid. The FTC advises car shoppers to get offer details in writing and warns that important details can sit in the fine print, and the same habit protects you as a seller.

CarPresto calls its first number a market estimate because the appraisal sets the firm offer. You can compare the ways to sell side by side, including fees.

How do you get a market estimate and a firm offer from CarPresto?

Start online and finish at a VIP Automotive Group dealership. There are no seller fees at any step, and you are paid by check at handoff.

  1. Get your market estimate with your VIN or plate, mileage and ZIP. It is good for 7 days.
  2. Book a free in-person appraisal at one of our dealership locations and pick a day and time.
  3. Get your firm offer at the visit. It stands for 7 days and includes your $500 bonus.
  4. Accept, sign and hand over the keys, and you are paid by check at handoff. Bring what to have ready.
  5. If you still have a loan, we verify the payoff and pay the lender directly after handoff. See loans and payoff and our guide to selling a car with a loan.

If you plan to buy your next car at the same time, read trade in or sell before you decide.

Common questions

Can a car buyer lower the price after an inspection?

Many buyers can, because their first number depends on an inspection. With CarPresto, the firm offer is made at the appraisal, after the car has been seen. It stays subject to the car matching what you reported, plus title and payoff verification.

How long is a CarPresto market estimate good for?

It is good for 7 days, and the date is shown with it. Book your appraisal within that window to get a firm offer.

Do I have to accept the firm offer?

No. You can decline the firm offer, skip the appraisal or simply stop at any point before you sign the purchase agreement, with no penalty and nothing owed.

Does the appraisal cost anything?

No. The appraisal is free, and CarPresto charges no appraisal, admin, processing or listing fee. Everything is itemized before you sign.

What happens if my firm offer expires?

You can request a refreshed offer from your portal. Market prices move, so the refreshed amount can be higher or lower than the first one.

Sources

Rules and fees change. Check the agency page before you file anything. This guide is general information from CarPresto, not legal or tax advice.

Thinking about selling?

See your market estimate in about two minutes. Your firm offer comes at a free appraisal. No fees.